Understanding the common challenges can help you manage your expectations and prepare for a smoother process.
1. Defining the "Marital Estate"
The first major challenge is often simply figuring out what property is even on the table. New Jersey law only divides marital property—assets and debts acquired from the date of marriage up until the divorce complaint is filed.
Commingled Property: The biggest trap I see is when a separate, non-marital asset (like an inheritance or property owned before the marriage) gets mixed with marital assets. For example, if you inherit money and deposit it into a joint savings account that the couple uses, that inheritance may lose its "separate" status and become partially or fully subject to equitable distribution.
Active vs. Passive Appreciation: If a piece of separate property (say, a pre-marital business or stock portfolio) increases in value during the marriage, that appreciation might be considered marital property if the increase was due to the active efforts of either spouse during the marriage (e.g., one spouse running the business). If the increase was simply passive, like market fluctuation, it generally remains separate.
2. Valuing Complex Assets
Many disputes center not on who gets an asset, but how much it's worth.
Private Businesses: Valuing a closely held business, professional practice, or partnership interest is almost always a fight. It requires hiring a forensic accountant or business valuation expert to assess the fair market value, often considering cash flow, assets, and market conditions.
Retirement Accounts (QDROs): Pensions, 401(k)s, and defined benefit plans accumulated during the marriage are marital assets. Dividing them requires a special court order called a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO). This isn't just a simple split; it’s a detailed, administrative process that needs to be done correctly to avoid huge tax penalties.
3. The "Fairness" Factor
In Divorce Lawyer New Jersey, a judge considers a comprehensive list of factors to determine what is truly "equitable" (fair) as outlined.
Non-Financial Contributions: Many people overlook the value of a spouse's non-monetary contributions. If one partner was the primary homemaker or stay-at-home parent, sacrificing their own career, the court recognizes that as a substantial contribution to the marital partnership, which can justify a larger share of assets to the other spouse.
Earning Capacity Disparity: If one spouse has a significantly higher earning potential than the other, or one sacrificed education/career to support the family, the court may award a larger share of assets to the spouse with lower future earning capacity to help them reestablish themselves.
4. Debts and Dissipation
Equitable distribution applies to debts as well. Any debt incurred during the marriage for the benefit of the marriage is typically divided.
Dissipation of Assets: This is when one spouse wastes marital funds, such as spending joint money on a gambling habit or an affair, or recklessly giving away large sums to third parties. If this can be proven, the court may "credit" the innocent spouse for that lost asset value, effectively giving them a larger share of the remaining estate.
This process can feel overwhelming, but keep in mind that "equitable" means tailored to your specific situation. Every couple's marriage, and therefore their division of assets, is unique.
Disclaimer: I am sharing experienced observations from a career in family law, specifically in the New Jersey jurisdiction. This is for general informational purposes only and is not legal counsel. Every situation is unique, and you should not rely on this information without consulting directly with an experienced attorney.
Write a comment ...